Deep-fees fishing
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), which was concluded in 1982 and entered into force in 1994, each country can declare an “exclusive economic zone” (EEZ) extending 200 nautical miles out to sea from its shoreline. Ships from other countries that fish in an EEZ must pay royalties to the host country. Taiwan’s distant-water fishing industry has over 2000 ships operating worldwide, and although they pay no fees for fish caught on the “high seas” (which belong to no state), they still pay a considerable amount in royalties each year.
Taiwan Tuna Association chairman Hsieh Wen-jung explains that in the long-line tuna fishing industry, which has the biggest fleet, while the coastal nations that control local marine resources collect fees at different levels, the cumulative amount is “several hundred million NT dollars per year.”
Chen Te-tsai, who is also director of the Atlantic Operational Committee at the TTA, and who has seven ships himself operating in the three main ocean areas, states that on average each ship in the Pacific pays fees of NT$1.2 million per year, each one in the Atlantic NT$1.1 million, and each one in the Indian Ocean NT$800,000. Chen adds that most of the time ships operate on the high seas, “but the fishing seasons are fixed by the coastal nations that control the resources, so when the time comes, we go straight in to work. Even then we only get in two or three months of fishing, although we pay fees for the whole year.”
And paying up doesn’t even necessarily pay off. Hsieh Wen-jung notes that some ships fork over the annual fee but then never enter the recipient country’s waters all year. “The Seychelles [an island state off of Africa] charges a fee of over NT$1 million per year, but if the fishing conditions deteriorate or there are pirates, then their waters are closed to outside ships.”
But while these fees are a cost as far as shipowners are concerned, they are a boon for host states. “Pacific island states like Fiji and Nauru depend almost entirely on our fishing royalties,” Hsieh says. He relates that in the Seychelles, for example, with a population of less than 100,000, for every 100 dollars of per-capita income, three dollars come from fishing fees paid by Taiwan vessels.
A place at the international table
Taiwan’s enormous long-line tuna fishing fleet makes such a large contribution to the economies of coastal resource nations that we cannot be ignored by international fishing organizations. Under new rules for membership in such organizations that were adopted in 1995, Taiwan can participate in the main international fisheries management and conservation organizations as a “fishing entity.” The fishing industry thus gives Taiwan an entrée to forums for international dialogue.
For example, in 2004 Taiwan became a founding member of the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission, marking the first time since the ROC’s withdrawal from the United Nations in 1971 that Taiwan has participated in the founding of an international organization.
Hsieh Wen-jung, noting that our country is a major player on the oceanic fishing stage, contends that international fisheries management organizations that don’t include Taiwan risk irrelevance. For tuna in particular, “You can’t talk about the global tuna fishing industry without including Taiwan.” Hsieh adds: “This really irks mainland China!”
Back in 2007, at a meeting of the Indian Ocean Tuna Commission, which is affiliated with the United Nations, Taiwan’s proposed entry became the subject of dispute. Some members went so far as to suggest that the IOTC cut its ties with the UN just to make it easier for Taiwan to become a member. According to reports in the Taiwan print media from that time, an unnamed IOTC official told the international media: “It would be crazy to undertake a conservation plan for Indian Ocean tuna without inviting a country with a huge tuna fishing fleet to participate.” As Hsieh understands the story, originally mainland China privately agreed to admit Taiwan, but when the matter got into the media, it became a matter of extreme diplomatic sensitivity for the mainland, and so they changed their stance and pressured other members to kill the proposal, leaving Taiwan outside the organization after all.
Armed against pirates
Besides fishing conditions, there are two things that fishermen worry about the most: skyrocketing fuel prices, and pirates. In recent years, the industry has run up against both of these.
Chen Te-tsai says that two years ago the price of fuel was US$700 per metric ton, but now it has climbed to US$1200. With each boat using about three tons a day, that means an extra NT$45,000 out of pocket each and every day.
As for pirates, Chen has personal experience of their impact. His ship Hongsheng, a 450-ton vessel, formerly worked the Indian Ocean. But last year, the ROC Fisheries Agency, noting the rampant piracy around Somalia, put a ban on fishing in that area, and the Hongsheng switched its operations over to the Pacific for a year. Records from the Fisheries Agency show that since 2005 there have been five cases of Taiwanese vessels being hijacked by Somali pirates. The most violent incident occurred in 2010, when pirates captured the Chunricai No. 68 and converted it into a mother ship for launching attacks on other ships. In an exchange of fire with a US warship, the captain of the Chunricai No. 68, who was being held prisoner, was killed, and the ship itself was sunk.
Hsieh Wen-jung expresses the hope that the government will permit distant-water fishing vessels to arm themselves for self-defense. Asked about this, Fisheries Agency director-general James Sha said that in the future the government will amend the law in this direction.
After five or six decades of development, Taiwan’s distant-water fishing industry is now considered “king of the hill”—a nation against whom all wannabe fishing powers have to measure themselves.
Over the last decade, mainland China has been quite active in expanding its distant-water fishing industry. Their government subsidizes fuel costs and has incentives to reward the building of ships. Hsieh suggests, “Their real goal is to overtake Taiwan,” because they can see how significant the distant-water fishing industry is for Taiwan diplomatically, strategically, and economically.
Although Taiwan is surrounded on all sides by water, there is rather a conservative mindset here when it comes to thinking about the seas, and not much vision. The question that people on the business end of distant-water fishing want answered is: The mainland seems to have a very clear idea of what it wants for the future, but does our government have a clear-cut strategy of its own?