Crises, opportunities, and severed arms
Eight-man tug of war was introduced to Taiwan in 1992. One of the strongest proponents of it here has been Wu Wenda, respected elder statesman of Taiwanese sport and promoter of Japanese-Taiwanese sporting exchanges.
When the sport came to Taiwan, Wu considered it perfect for the Taiwanese people; with its clear rules and quick matches; lack of restrictions on age, place, or class of competitor; and strict regulations on weight classes that guarantee fair fights. He saw tug of war as a sport in which Taiwanese competitors could stand up against their more physically imposing Western counterparts. Thus inspired, Wu founded the Chinese Taipei Tug of War Association and began promoting the sport around Taiwan’s cities and counties, and particularly at elementary and middle schools.
In 1997, with the sport blossoming, the Taipei City Government and the Taipei Culture Foundation joined together to challenge the Guinness world record for tug of war, even giving the event an air of ancient times by consulting writings from the Tang Dynasty on the competitions of that era. However, not long after the contest started, the rope gave way, injuring several participants, and even severing two people’s left arms.
Explaining the incident, Chinese Taipei Tug of War Association general secretary Zhuo Yaopeng explains that in tug of war, the rope is placed under tremendous stress, which is why there are strict regulations on the materials used for international competition ropes, along with their length and thickness. However at that point few in Taiwan took tug of war seriously enough to worry about safety precautions, and that is what led to such a terrible accident.
Sisters are doing it for themselves
Having learned from that lesson, in 1998 the Ministry of Education strongly encouraged adherence to international standards for tug of war. In addition to organizing the annual National All-Levels Schools Tug of War Competition, the ministry also began promoting training for umpires and coaches. Eventually eight-man tug of war began to make its way into Taiwanese schools, and today, hundreds of school teams take part in tug-of-war competitions nationwide every year.
As tug of war’s popularity grew, people began looking toward the next stage—international competition.
Cai Sanxiong, former Taiwanese national team coach and trainer of both Guo Sheng, coach at Jingmei Girls’ High, and Chen Jianwen, Nantou Senior High coach, notes that at first Taiwan’s results were less than fantastic, but the coaches and the teams never gave up, using these frustrations as chances to gain experience.
In 2000, the Taiwanese women’s indoor team took sixth place at the World Cup, finally making a name for the nation on the international stage. In the years that followed, Taiwan’s “strongwomen” developed their tactics and grew in experience, not only becoming World Cup and Asian Cup champions, but even turning in back-to-back top-of-the-table performances in the 520-kg class at the 2005 and 2009 World Games.
Team Taiwan’s surprising stamina
Many wonder how it is that Taiwan has managed to succeed so well internationally, given the far more physically imposing competition it faces from Europe and America.
“Tug of war is much more about defense than offense,” remarks Zhuo. During matches, the two teams may look stock still, but in reality the competitors are focusing all of their energy into their feet, desperately working to keep their bodies in balance with the rope. However, as time crawls by, eventually someone’s muscles will give, their steps or posture slackening ever so slightly; this weakens the whole team’s grip on the rope, and offers the opposition a chance to strike.
“Tug of war is a game of stamina, not brute force! Physical strength is more about natural gifts, but stamina is more about tough training, and that’s where Taiwan shines,” says Zhuo. By way of example, he points to the World Cup performance of the Jingmei Girls’ High team. At first, they may have looked to be at a disadvantage, but their opposition often found that once they got Jingmei to just 10 centimeters from the centerline, they just couldn’t get the girls to budge any further no matter how hard they tried. And while they heaved and heaved as Jingmei stood firm, their own energy was slowly being sapped. Then, their opponents weakened, Jingmei would seize the opportunity to counterattack, often turning the tables completely in one pull.
Another part of the superlative success of Taiwan’s women’s teams has been their determination to test themselves against physically stronger men’s teams; this way, when matched against the imposing teams from the West, they remain unfazed.
“The men’s teams, though, find it immensely difficult to find someone tougher than themselves,” says Zhuo, “so their results haven’t been nearly as impressive as the women’s teams.”
Zen and the art of tug of war
As many as 80% of Taiwan’s tug-of-war representatives today come from underprivileged families. With less-than-outstanding academic records and physical abilities a little shy of letting them break out as stars of ball sports or athletic events, they often throw themselves into tug of war, seeing it as the only way to get into good schools.
However, if it’s more about getting into a good school than it is about passion for the sport, they’ll most likely not have the fortitude to keep going down the tough tug-of-war path: “How many girls in the flower of youth are going to put up with calloused and cut-up hands, or with the constant demands to bulk up or slim down to get to competition weight?” asks Zhuo.
Jingmei Girls’ High coach Guo Sheng adds that tug of war can be a very monotonous kind of sport, without the kind of instant feedback that, say, basketball gives when you sink a shot. But what it does have is a powerful emphasis on teamwork, so team members often develop much closer bonds than people in other sports.
In fact, tug of war is a very philosophical kind of sport. It doesn’t create individual superstars, instead putting the team above all; it is a sport where sometimes the best way forward is backward, where defense is more important than offense. Tug of war is in many ways a Zen sport.
And perhaps it is some kind of Zen enlightenment that enables Taiwan’s tug of war competitors not only to continue to test themselves in one heated battle after another, but to come out victorious.