The root of the problem
Chien Chiung-jen, author of the book The Taiwan People's Party, says that the intellectuals in the anti-Japanese movement had one major difference from the great literati of feudal society. They mixed with the common people, and were concerned about the problems of ordinary citizens, and from this powerful programs and ideas emerged. Only in this way were they able to organize the masses and create serious problems for the authorities. Looking back at all the leaders of that era, Chiang Wei-shui could be said to be the one who was closest to the common man.
Why Chiang? Huang Huang-hsiung argues that Chiang Wei-shui naturally was the type to mix with the masses as a result of both his family background (his father and grandfather were fortune-tellers) and his role as a doctor. He also was of a naturally gregarious character, as is evident from his opening two restaurants when he was practicing medicine in the bustling Tataocheng area of Taipei, and he was not snobbish, accepting people regardless of their social status. Another factor is that when he was in prison, he came into daily contact with gangsters, opium addicts, and prostitutes, after which he showed even greater sympathy for the weak and disadvantaged.
The Taiwan Minpao carried many excerpts from the notebooks that Chiang kept in prison. From them we can see that he not only made friends with gangsters, but was quite interested in the culture and language of their world, and planned to produce a dictionary of gangster lingo after coming out of prison. At the same time, he was deeply pained by the way the gangsters wasted their courage on fighting against their guards, frequently being injured and growing weak and dispirited as a result. What he found even more tragic, he wrote, is that "I can feel that in the future there will be more and more wasted lives like this in Taiwan. Under the policies of the colonial regime, the poorer the Taiwanese become, the more lower class families will be disrupted, and the more children will grow up bereft of proper moral instruction."
On another occasion, following an incident in which the opium addict in his cell lost control of his bowels and defecated all over the cell, Chiang Wei-shui wrote: "The most despised and hated people in this prison are the opium addicts. When a man gets to this level, he has no pride or dignity left at all."
Once Chiang saw two child prostitutes who were also inmates sweeping up, and he found them not unlike Lin Daiyu of Dream of the Red Chamber fame. "If they had grown up in wealthy families [like Lin Daiyu], wouldn't they have become delicate and refined young ladies?" When the gangsters and ne'er-do-wells insulted the prostitutes, Chiang reminded them that they should be more sympathetic, for they all suffered from the same conditions of poverty and oppression. He urged them to wake up to the fact that they were all disadvantaged, and should unite together and struggle for the liberation of Taiwan.
This deep love for his homeland and his great sympathy for his fellow man were steeled by the era and the environment into a great sense of mission on behalf of his compatriots. This sense of mission in turn allowed him to inspire and organize people into political and social movements.
Today there are a number of different spins put on Chiang Wei-shui. Some consider him a pioneer Taiwanese nationalist, but others see him as identifying with Chinese nationalism. Some label him leftist while others say that he was no such thing. Leaving aside for a moment questions of left and right, Taiwan and China, how is it that people from all over the political spectrum so respect Chiang Wei-shui? Perhaps it is only by getting back to the question of character that one can really see the true face of this historic figure.