Stonewalling
According to Li Kuo-sheng, the comfort women issue was one of the most despicable episodes of World War II. In mainland China, Hainan Island, Hong Kong, the Philippines, Indonesia, Burma, Okinawa, Korea, and Taiwan, "Wherever the Japanese army went, they took comfort women with them."
During the war in the Pacific, Japan sent 3.5 million soldiers overseas, and women from mainland China, Korea, and Taiwan were forced to go along. Chu Te-lan and others estimate that over 100,000 Koreans, 20,000 Japanese, at least 1,200 Taiwanese, and over 200,000 mainland Chinese women were forced by the Japanese to serve as comfort women during World War II.
In an effort to enhance their military capabilities and achieve victory in war, the Japanese used the power of the state to coerce women into military prostitution. They exploited women who happened to find themselves in relatively disadvantageous circumstances. This, more than anything else, is what has brought such furious condemnation upon the Japanese in connection with the comfort women issue. Li Kuo-sheng writes, "They used the official apparatus of state to establish a system of legalized rape. " Says Chu Te-lan, "Probably no other country in history had ever done such a thing before." What really irks people is that the Japanese government has never once made a sincere apology.
Chu points out that some academics and government officials in Japan argue that the former Taiwanese and Korean comfort women who have spoken out in the 1990s on their wartime experiences have been lying about forced prostitution. Tokyo University professor Fujioka Nobukatsu, for example, has stated, "The comfort women were not sex slaves. They were just prostitutes whose pimps took them to the war front. In Korea almost all the pimps were Korean." He has also said, "All those stories about Japanese wartime atrocities are pure fabrications."
Women's groups in Asia have gone on the offensive to counter these ideas. Since 1992, groups in South Korea, the Philippines, Japan, and Taiwan have worked with victims from throughout Asia to hold five joint conferences on the comfort women issue. Large numbers of former comfort women have come forward on each of these occasions to tell their stories. Ho Pi-chen, chief executive officer of TWRF, strongly contests the contention of the Japanese government that the comfort women were engaged in private prostitution. In talking with former comfort women from many different countries, Ho has learned: "Most of these women were transported to the front on naval vessels. The comfort stations were built by the military, and the military determined how they were to be run. When the women got sick, they were attended to by military doctors. The brokers who recruited the women and the mama-sans who watched over the comfort stations all had close ties with the Japanese military."
A small number of right-minded Japanese scholars have published studies that contradict the stand of their government. In 1992, Chuo University history professor Yoshimi Yoshiaki published the first paper documenting the participation of the Japanese military in the comfort women scheme. The public airing of military documents concerning the recruitment and transport of comfort women during World War II forced the Japanese government to publicly acknowledge military involvement in the establishment of comfort stations. In 1993, Chief Cabinet Secretary Kono Yohei apologized to the victims, and Prime Minister Murayama Tomiichi followed suit in 1994. These apologies represented a positive signal by the Japanese government, but they were made under duress.
A positive signal, however, is only a signal. Just as in the case of Taiwanese soldiers who fought for Japan, the Japanese government has not yielded any ground on the issue of compensation. Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs contends that the issue of compensation for wartime misdeeds was put to rest with the signing of the San Francisco Peace Treaty. The Japanese government is only willing to use privately collected donations to compensate former comfort women for their suffering. In the view of Ho Pi-chen, "In other words, it means the government doesn't want to have anything to do with the payment of compensation."
To angry Taiwanese victims, the Japanese government's attitude translates to this: "They don't admit any wrongdoing." That is what motivated the lawsuit filed this past July in Tokyo District Court.
Wang Ching-feng, a lawyer and former chairwoman of the Taipei Women's Rescue Foundation, has worked for many years on behalf of Taiwan's former comfort women. She hopes to use this issue to warn against further such wartime savagery.