Transnational linkages
The fair trade production chain differs from the traditional model in that the end link—the actual makers—have to be contacted individually across national boundaries. Vinka Yang and Elizabeth Tsai spent virtually the entire half-year starting in the summer of 2010 researching the techniques, materials, and operating rules of production organizations belonging to the WFTO. Because no one in Taiwan had any experience with this business model, they were basically pioneering brand new territory entirely on their own.
“When we first started to contact these overseas production organizations,” recalls Yang, “we got very few encouraging responses.” Some people even asked, “Where is Taiwan? In Asia or in Europe?” But after numerous explanations, these organizations finally began mailing DVD catalogues of the products their factories could make to Taiwan, allowing Twine to study their unique features and styles and make orders.
In April of 2011 Twine finally got the go-ahead for cooperation from two NGOs, with neither of the two orders exceeding US$1000. One was a women’s organization in Ghana, specializing in making soap, glass, and batik products. The other was a factory in Bangladesh using recycled concrete packaging to make bags. Yang and Tsai were overjoyed when they got the news. And in the two years since, Twine has gone from a starting point of absolute zero to a total of 30 cooperative producer organizations, stretching from Africa across the Middle East to the South Asian countries of Bangladesh, India, and Nepal, and has become the nexus of a fair-trade production network.
With the production chain taking shape, the next thing on the agenda was for Yang and Tsai to formally apply to join the WFTO.
Under the WFTO, both the seller and the producer must be certified in order for the product to use the WFTO label. The seller, in order to get certified, must meet two conditions: (1) they must have had at least two years of continuous cooperation with the producer, and (2) they must provide complete documentation, including records of fund transfers between the two parties, a financial statement proving sustainability of operations, records of sales levels to date, and a mission statement for the future of their business.
Once approved, Twine would have to pay an annual fee of about €400. Moreover, the owners would have to regularly go to the producer country to determine whether the conditions there meet WFTO norms, and send a written report to the WFTO.
After a year of effort, in March of 2013 Twine received formal approval to join the World Free Trade Organization, becoming the first cultural/creative brand in Taiwan to join, and essentially making a promise to incorporate global economic justice into their operations. They guarantee that one-half of the sales price will go to the producer, and that the producer organization pays decent wages and is not simply an exploitative factory.
Stainless steel lunchboxes and adorable animal-shaped eye pillows are among the top-selling items at Twine.