The site's importance, part two:
Delimiting the spread of Neolithic culture
Still more importantly, the excavation of the Chienshan prehistoric site has provided a resolution to a long-running debate within Taiwan's archaeological community over the cultural inheritance of the Yuanshan and Botanical Garden cultures.
Liu explains that carbon-14 dating has shown the oldest human artifacts discovered in Taiwan to be about 6,000-plus years old, and says that there has been a direct line of transmission from the island's prehistoric inhabitants to its present-day indigenes.
"Change and rupture are two different things," says Liu vis-a-vis the dispute. "If the Jews were expelled from Israel, for example, and all trace of them disappeared from that area, that would be a rupture. The development of Austronesians on Taiwan involves only change, not rupture. But, as the culture has been handed down, have local or external factors provided the impetus to change? The question is worth investigating."
Archaeological finds on Taiwan reveal two principal late Neolithic cultures on the island--the Yuanshan and the Botanical Garden. The two cultures spanned about 2,500 years of history, with the former beginning its spread about 4,500 years ago and the latter persisting until about 2,000 years ago. The question is, was the Botanical Garden culture descended from the Yuanshan, or did external forces allow it to destroy and replace the Yuanshan? Taiwan's archaeological community has long been vexed by questions about the nature of the relationship between these two cultures.
As early as the 1960s, Professor Chang Kwang-chih noted that Botanical Garden archaeological finds included pottery implements featuring a diamond pattern remarkably similar to one previously identified with the southeast coast of mainland China, suggesting a cultural system recently transplanted to Taiwan. Meanwhile, Liu's teacher, NTU anthropology professor Sung Wen-hsun, has proposed that there is no direct link between the Yuanshan and the other prehistoric cultures of northern Taiwan. Instead, he believes that it was the Yuanshan culture that originated outside of Taiwan in mainland China's Han River basin (which includes eastern Guangdong and southern Fujian), arguing that their ethnicity, language, tools and customs were all different from those of Taiwan's Austronesian indigenes.
Other scholars disagree. They argue that there is no distinct "Botanical Garden culture," but that there is instead a single culture with a Yuanshan period and a Botanical Garden period denoting the different stages in its development. This diversity of opinion has so far made it impossible to definitively map the origins and movements of Taiwan's prehistoric peoples.
The discovery of the Chienshan prehistoric site has shed light on this issue. The Academia Sinica archaeological team preliminarily dated finds from the Chienshan site to the time period of both cultural strata, while carbon-14 dating has identified them as spanning a 2,500-year period. Liu further argues that stone tools from the site show characteristics of Botanical Garden tools and the form of Yuanshan tools, demonstrating a gradual evolution. Holding up a fragment of a Chienshan stone tool, Liu explains that it places both the Yuanshan and Botanical Garden cultures within the context of the ongoing development of the Austronesian cultural system. It's just that the introduction of external factors in the interim between the two impacted their development, giving the Botanical Gardens culture a somewhat different look. For the moment, the nature of this small number of external factors remains uncertain.
As the school bells ring out the end of class, the playground quickly fills with an occupying army of elementary-school children. Hard at work, the archaeological team prays that the children tearing around the field don't crush any of the 3,000-year-old relics of their ancestors. They also pray that this lost world will someday be revealed again, and its broken remains transformed into treasures cherished in the children's hearts.
A prehistoric archaeological site discovered at Dayuan Primary School during construction 60 years ago came to light again last year during renovations to the campus. Finds have included pottery shards and stone tools from two cultural strata--the Yuanshan and the Botanical Garden strata.
A prehistoric archaeological site discovered at Dayuan Primary School during construction 60 years ago came to light again last year during renovations to the campus. Finds have included pottery shards and stone tools from two cultural strata--the Yuanshan and the Botanical Garden strata.
A prehistoric archaeological site discovered at Dayuan Primary School during construction 60 years ago came to light again last year during renovations to the campus. Finds have included pottery shards and stone tools from two cultural strata--the Yuanshan and the Botanical Garden strata.
A prehistoric archaeological site discovered at Dayuan Primary School during construction 60 years ago came to light again last year during renovations to the campus. Finds have included pottery shards and stone tools from two cultural strata--the Yuanshan and the Botanical Garden strata.