Into the mainland!
A lot of people are certainly curious as to why Artilize started out so far from home. CEO Tseng responds that they were by no means confident that mainland Chinese customers would be very enthusiastic about the mainly Asian aesthetics of their products. Moreover, the sale of upmarket products in the mainland market quickly elicits a flood of cheap local knockoffs. But when the global financial tsunami hit in 2008, demand in the US and European markets sharply declined, while mainland China's domestic market was growing stronger by the day, so Artilize decided to head into the mainland despite these concerns.
Tseng soon discovered, "People in the mainland feel a strong sense of pride about Chinese culture." As mainland Chinese have grown wealthier, the market for home decorating products has taken off, and appears to have virtually unlimited potential. With five years of experience selling to the West under their belts, the folks at Artilize adopted the following strategy: Whereas in the West they were content to sell through a "Tales Corner" in existing home furnishings stores, they decided that, in order to ensure the integrity of the brand name in mainland China, they were going to have to open their own specialized outlets.
But the mainland is enormous, and Artilize, given its scale of operations, couldn't go in for directly managed outlets, but would have to operate through local agents. Unfortunately, every sales channel and every city in the mainland has its own operating customs, each with its own pros and cons, so the company faced the enormous challenge of coming up with a model or models for developing operating channels.
"There's a basketful of people in mainland China who will act as local agents, but it's not easy to find just the right person," says Tseng. Artilize was not in any panic to get into the mainland market, and decided to be satisfied with growing only as fast as their network of local agents. Right now they have seven outlets in places like Beijing, Shanghai, and Hefei, and plan to expand to over ten locations by the end of this year.
It has also been necessary to overcome differences in the way people on one side of the Taiwan Strait think and work compared to the other side. Creative people in Taiwan love to cross disciplinary boundaries to see what they can find, but that's not common in the mainland. The main model there is to train people according to some standard operating procedures, with each department-product displays, sales, whatever-having its own people that concentrate only on doing their one task well. But after years of rubbing shoulders with Taiwanese colleagues, and sometimes coming to loggerheads with them, mainlanders have gotten used to the idea of getting more training and experience outside the box.
The museum market
In the three years they have been in the mainland market, Artilize has focused not only on the two major markets of retail sales and custom-made production of products for large corporate clients, but more recently has begun to see the profit opportunities in museums. Tseng, who has "an acute sense of sell," has found that museums in mainland China have large and rapidly growing "hardware" resources, but lack the "software" skills needed to make their institution stand out above the rest. This presents a great opportunity to the creative and cultural industry in Taiwan.
Artilize has already reached agreements to work together with several quite famous museums in the mainland on projects that include corporate identity, product planning, manufacturing, establishment of sales outlets, and international marketing, even going so far as to train museum personnel for participation in overseas exhibitions.
Tony Tseng says that the spin-off products developed by museums not only bring in revenues, they are living advertisements. The National Palace Museum in Taipei, the Metropolitan in New York, and the Louvre in France all have done very well in this respect, but mainland museums, though having the inevitable gift shops, just don't do enough to put more substance and creativity into their spin-off products.
Tseng spends a lot of time traveling back and forth between Taiwan and the mainland. What does he think the prospects are for complementarity between the human resources on the two sides?
"There is a deep foundation of handicrafts and materials production all over China, everywhere you go," he says. "But they could do with some help from the Taiwan side, some creative ideas and organizational skills, to make them shine brilliantly once more." For example, in Yunnan you'll find extraordinary craftsmanship in silver and tinwork. Tseng hopes to integrate these metals into embellishments for his ceramics products, each material raising the other to a new level and inspiring greater creativity and more elevated aesthetics.
However, he also advises: "There's no need to overly stress preconceived notions that 'Taiwan does this, the mainland does that.' What's important is the coordination of resources and assets on both sides, with everyone working together to create successful brands."